Children’s Bible Stories?

A year ago, a little girl told my (non-church-going) niece that she was going to Hell because she didn’t know a particular Bible story. This has all worked itself out in the meantime, with the two little girls each coming to a broader understanding of the world, and becoming friends. But one lingering effect of the initial trauma has been my niece’s conviction that in order to understand certain people, she is going to need to know about the Bible.
I would know just how to proceed if she were 14. But from what I have been able to see, the quality of younger children’s Bible story books is, at best, inadequate. Story lines are altered to suit rhyming schemes, works righteousness abounds, God is everywhere “He,” and the single thrust of most every story is that it is our bounden duty to tell everyone that Christ died to save them from damnation – even if the story is from the Old Testament. (See, for instance, Arch Books’ Zerubbabel Rebuilds the Temple.)
This may be an evangelical strategy, but it seems doomed to be an evangelistically ineffective one – families who are not churchgoers are going to be so turned off by these stories that they wash their hands of the Bible entirely and move on to Old Turtle. And so I had been fantasizing about writing my own series of children’s picture books from the Bible – that this might not be another lost opportunity to introduce children to Christianity.
It is a popular argument that the Bible is not particularly kid friendly. The stories we tell to children from the Old Testament are almost comically grim: the expulsion from the Garden, David killing and decapitating Goliath, Jonah swallowed by a giant fish, Ananias and Sapphira struck dead for lying… “Noah’s Ark” is a great example of this – not in reality a story mainly about a bunch of animals living peaceably together on a dear little wooden ship, but unavoidably a story about the death of all humanity except for 8 people (and all of the arguably blameless animals but two (or 7) of each species) at the hands of an angry God.

But even this is nothing compared to the stories we dare not tell children – Tamara raped by her brother, Jezebel torn apart by dogs… so I have begun to agree that perhaps the Bible really is not a book for children. My niece is right to think that the Bible is an essential book, but perhaps wrong to consider that she therefore needs to know all about it right now, as a second-grader. I hope that one day she reads Crime and Punishment, too, but by “one day” I mean “when she is sixteen or older” – and again every five to ten years. I am not in the meantime frantically scouring bookstores for the storybook version.
The Bible is a diverse collection of texts, so naturally there are passages which I would except from my “this is no book for children” dictum – but most of them are not the narratives. For instance, I recently came across a beautiful rendering of Ecclesiastes 3:1-8 for children (To Everything There is a Season, by Jude Daly.) Certain Psalms would lend themselves to this sort of treatment, certain sayings of Jesus and passages from Paul and Isaiah.

But on the whole it seems that we are more in need of Tolkien-esque authors – writers who can write stories that illustrate the themes and truths of Christianity in new settings – settings that do not necessarily invoke Christ, but rather evoke Christianity.
What do you think? Are Biblical narratives suitable for children? What are some of your recommendations for books for readers under 10? Not only Bible stories, but also those books which point towards the insights of the Christian faith?

6 responses

  1. Pingback: Is the Bible a Book for Children, or, Do You Like to Talk to Tomatoes? « Ramblings from Red Rose

    • Thanks to Will for his thoughtful response! I hope that you all check out his blog – not just this entry, but his archives, too. Will and I have had many fruitful theological conversations over the years, and I am glad to be continuing the conversation in our blogs!

  2. I found you via Will.

    Here are a few thoughts.

    Our family started reading Harry Potter as a family read before all my children were 10, and they loved it. There are powerful Christian themes in there despite all the folks who want to burn them for talking about witches.

    Tomie de Paolo has some excellent picture books – both religious and not.

    Chris van Allsburgh is a wonderful author/illustrator. The Polar Express – book and movie – is a powerful story about the importance of belief.

  3. I need to figure out how to work in Margaret Wise Brown’s “The Runaway Bunny” into my intro the theology class. Simple but profound discussion of a mother’s love reflective of God’s love and pursuit of us (a la Julian of Norwich’s “Showings”).

  4. Here I am commenting nearly 2 years later! But I was particularly thinking of this post today, and considering that Corduroy (which I wrote about in a later blog post: https://jerusalemtojericho.wordpress.com/2010/08/19/first-the-good-news/) is a particularly good book of the kind I am talking about.
    I haven’t read the Runaway Bunny in forever, and should certainly pick it up – but I have finally gotten around to reading the Harry Potter books, and have lots more to say about them than could be contained in a comment.
    And finally, I have discovered, through my friend Sarah Musser, a mostly good, in large part even wonderful children’s book of Bible stories called the Jesus Storybook Bible. Definitely worth taking a look at.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s